Knesset Erupts as Tibi Clashes With Bereaved Mother Over Hamas Condemnation

A tense Knesset debate over the Speaker's election turned explosive when Arab lawmaker Ahmad Tibi clashed with a bereaved mother who lost her son on October 7, refusing to explicitly condemn Hamas.

Knesset Erupts as Tibi Clashes With Bereaved Mother Over Hamas Condemnation
Photo: נועם מושקוביץ, דוברות הכנסת

The Knesset plenum descended into sharp uproar during a marathon and tense debate over the election of the Speaker of the 26th Knesset, following a bitter confrontation between an Arab party leader and a bereaved mother whose son fell in combat during the October 7 massacres.

The incident erupted when Ahmad Tibi of the Joint List took the podium to deliver an address accusing right-wing lawmakers of hypocrisy and racism toward the Arab public and its elected representatives. Tibi's remarks instantly drew fierce condemnation and outrage from the national camp benches.

Confrontation on the Knesset Floor

Amid the mounting tumult, newly elected lawmaker Taliq Goily—the mother of police officer Ran Goily, who fell heroically defending Kibbutz Alumim near the Gaza Strip—rose from her seat and directed a searing question at the speaker: "Who murdered my son?!"

Tibi responded from the rostrum by shifting responsibility, telling the bereaved mother to direct her grievances elsewhere: "Do not make insinuations. Address the Prime Minister—Hamas did it."

Undeterred, Goily pressed him with a direct moral challenge that has reverberated across Israeli politics since the outbreak of the war: "Then do you condemn Hamas?!"

Rather than explicitly condemning the terrorist organization responsible for the atrocities, Tibi demurred, stating only: "I condemned the atrocities."

Escalating Tensions and Political Fallout

This dramatic clash underscored the volatile atmosphere prevailing within the parliament following a series of contentious incidents. Just days earlier, Arab faction members including Tibi walked out of the Knesset plenum in defiance during the singing of the national anthem, Hatikvah, at the official swearing-in ceremony. Hours later, Tibi was recorded at a wedding in Umm al-Fahm proclaiming into a microphone that Arabs are "the masters of the land."

Right-wing lawmakers expressed fury that despite Arab faction leaders consistently dodging explicit condemnations of Hamas as a terrorist organization and making statements challenging national symbols, the center-left bloc led by Gadi Eisenkot appointed Tibi and Walid Taha as Deputy Speakers of the Knesset while pursuing close political cooperation to elect Matan Kahana as Speaker of the House.

Related News