Study Finds Israeli Vocational Training Programs Lack Impact Assessment
A joint Harvard and Tel Aviv University study reveals that Israeli vocational training non-profits with 1.4 billion shekels in annual revenue largely fail to track program efficiency.

A comprehensive joint study conducted by researchers from the Harvard Business School and Tel Aviv University reveals that the vocational training sector in Israel operates with virtually no reliable outcome tracking. The research, part of the Israel and the Regional Economy project, evaluated 88 nonprofit organizations operating training and career transition programs with a combined annual revenue of approximately 1.4 billion shekels.
Funding Streams and Evaluation Shortfalls
According to the findings, government allocations comprise 41.1 percent of the sector's total revenue, amounting to 576 million shekels. Philanthropic donations account for 35.1 percent, or 491 million shekels, while student participation fees and other sources generate 23.8 percent, representing 333 million shekels. Although these organizations implement a wide variety of curriculums addressing diverse barriers, their impact reports focus almost exclusively on direct participants without establishing proper comparison groups. The study highlights that even non-profits utilizing comparison groups fail to account for selection bias, leaving open the question of whether participants were pre-selected for higher aptitude or greater vulnerability.
Out of the 88 examined entities, only three organizations collect data in a manner that allows for unbiased evaluation of their actual effectiveness. The research team was led by Prof. Raffaella Sadun, Prof. Analia Schlosser, and Dr. Nahum Yaffe, alongside project manager Shahar Meshulam and researchers Jacques Hirsch and Jonah Weininger.
Economic Implications and Future Workforce
The authors emphasize that failing to measure program efficacy carries significant long-term costs. Ineffective programs risk receiving continued funding, while initiatives that succeed for specific demographics may be inappropriately expanded to populations where they yield negligible impact.
The researchers noted that rigorous evaluation is especially critical for Israel's economic future, as the ultra-Orthodox and Arab communities will comprise an increasingly large share of the working-age population in the coming decades.
"As time goes on, finding effective ways to integrate them into employment will have a growing impact on the entire Israeli labor market," the researchers stated, warning that the absence of verifiable evidence on non-profit programs remains a severe systemic vulnerability.
The study concludes that because gathering retrospective data is exceptionally difficult, systematic data collection must be integrated into programs from their inception, particularly for initiatives backed by substantial public or philanthropic funding.





