Tel Aviv Court Orders 50,000 Shekels in Expenses for Dismissed KSP Class Action
Israeli courts are increasingly imposing heavy legal costs on plaintiffs in dismissed class actions, highlighted by a Tel Aviv court ordering 50,000 shekels in expenses against a serial spam litigant in a case involving KSP.

Israeli courts are increasingly penalizing plaintiffs in rejected class-action lawsuits with substantial financial costs, signaling a tightening judicial approach toward frivolous legal filings. In a recent ruling, the Tel Aviv District Court dismissed a class-action suit against consumer electronics and mobile retailer KSP and ordered the plaintiff, serial spam litigation attorney Amit Zilberg, to pay 50,000 shekels in legal expenses.
The penalty stems from a broader judicial shift aimed at curbing abusive class actions, following a Supreme Court ruling issued in April. Historically, courts imposed lower cost orders to avoid discouraging public-interest plaintiffs. However, judges are now raising financial disincentives for unmerited claims, with recent cases seeing penalties reach up to 100,000 shekels when suits were filed with ulterior motives. Similarly, the Central District Court recently ordered Shufersal and McDonald's to receive 30,000 shekels each after dismissing spam-related class actions against them.
The KSP Legal Battle
The lawsuit against KSP was filed four years ago by attorneys Amit Zilberg and Ziv Glasberg, who alleged that the retailer had sent unsolicited commercial emails to customers who had opted out of promotional communications under the Communications Law. The case involved a single disputed marketing email, while subsequent messages concerned customer satisfaction surveys. Following two evidentiary hearings and the appointment of a court expert, Judge Rachel Arkubi ruled that Zilberg failed to prove he had opted out, whereas KSP presented system records showing he had consented.
Furthermore, the court determined that the communication error resulted from a minor human error and technical latency rather than a systemic policy violation. Judge Arkubi emphasized that the spam law was never intended to expose companies to massive liability over sporadic glitches involving processing time lags between campaign dispatch and unsubscription requests.
"The spam law was not designed to impose massive liabilities on a company solely due to sporadic incidents stemming from time gaps between sending a campaign and processing an opt-out request. That is not the purpose of the statute," Judge Arkubi ruled.
Divergent Outcomes for Plaintiffs
While Zilberg was ordered to pay 50,000 shekels after refusing the court's recommendation to withdraw from the proceedings, co-counsel Ziv Glasberg faced no financial penalty. The court acknowledged that Glasberg successfully proved he had not consented to receiving commercial emails, but ruled that a single isolated mistake did not justify pursuing an entire class-action procedure.
Although the court rejected the argument that the plaintiffs were acting entirely out of bad faith, it stressed that their extensive experience and involvement with anti-spam organizations impose a heightened duty of care and rigorous preliminary verification before initiating major legal actions.
Legal and Industry Reactions
Advocate Nati Agmon of EBN & Co., who represented KSP, welcomed the judicial decision.
"We welcome the ruling, which joins a growing trend of reining in class-action procedures in unwarranted cases," Agmon stated. "The class action is an essential tool for public protection, but not every localized glitch justifies activating such a powerful mechanism involving heavy costs and considerable judicial resources."
Conversely, Advocate Amit Zilberg criticized the verdict and confirmed plans to challenge the decision on appeal.
"The judgment is riddled with severe legal and evidentiary errors, and the court favored KSP's logs over my evidence despite the company admitting system failures," Zilberg noted. "This ruling sends a dangerous message that corporations can hide behind technical glitches while citizens seeking to enforce the law are deterred from seeking justice."





