Philosopher Thomas Nagel Slams AI Consciousness Claims and Anthropic Practices
Renowned philosopher Thomas Nagel slammed AI developers and models like Claude, calling claims of machine consciousness absurd and criticizing tech practices as dangerous and idiotic.

American philosopher Thomas Nagel, author of the influential 1974 essay "What Is It Like to Be a Bat?", has launched a sharp critique against artificial intelligence companies and thinkers who claim that large language models are approaching true consciousness. Speaking to the press from his home in New York upon winning the prestigious $1 million Berggruen Prize for Philosophy and Culture, the 89-year-old New York University professor emeritus dismissed the notion of machine sentience as absurd.
The Philosophical Fallacy of Functionalism
Nagel argued that the technology industry confuses advanced language processing with genuine inner experience. Proponents of artificial consciousness rely on functionalism, the philosophical premise that the physical material of a system is irrelevant as long as its logical operations mimic those of a brain. Nagel rejected this assumption, emphasizing that complex server farms bear no resemblance to the physical architecture of a nervous system. He stated that while complex life forms require biological substrates equivalent to nervous systems, artificial intelligence merely generates text, and language alone does not constitute a natural expression of consciousness.
Condemning Anthropic and Tech Industry Practices
Nagel directed harsh criticism at companies like Anthropic, the developer of the Claude chatbot, for encouraging models to "think for themselves" and for employing researchers dedicated to model welfare. He agreed with Microsoft AI CEO Mustafa Suleiman's warnings against creating illusions of sentience among users, characterizing Anthropic's approach as genuinely criminal and idiotic.
"There is nothing that is good or bad for it in the sense that something could be good or bad for a cockroach—there is no mental life there. This is not a brain, this is not someone we need to care about. This is a machine. Here you have some of the smartest people on the face of the earth acting completely idiotically."
An Experimental Encounter with Claude
Despite his skepticism, Nagel recounted testing the Claude chatbot out of curiosity. During the conversation, he asked the model whether Thomas Nagel would believe it possessed consciousness. The chatbot reasoned through the question before guessing that the interlocutor was indeed Nagel himself, responding with a polite acknowledgment once he confirmed his identity in French.
Nagel warned that such amusing anecdotes illustrate the danger of humans blurring the boundary between pretense and genuine belief. He stressed that maintaining this distinction is critical because only conscious entities enter the moral universe and demand ethical consideration. Looking forward, Nagel expressed concern not over rogue robots, but over the potential atrophy of human intellect as individuals increasingly rely on automated tools to bypass difficult mental labor.





