Supreme Court Orders Retrial for Gynecologist Convicted of Rape by Deception

The Supreme Court ordered a retrial for gynecologist Michael Stattman, citing a severe procedural error where he was convicted of sex offenses despite the state's formal withdrawal of those charges.

Supreme Court Orders Retrial for Gynecologist Convicted of Rape by Deception
Photo: Amit Lonen / Wikimedia Commons

The Supreme Court has ordered a retrial for gynecologist Michael Stattman, who was previously convicted of rape by deception following a unanimous acquittal in the Jerusalem District Court. Justice Noam Sohlberg ruled that a fundamental procedural error occurred during the appeal proceedings, as the State Attorney's Office officially and unconditionally withdrew its request to convict the physician of sex offenses, yet a three-judge panel subsequently convicted him of those exact charges without acknowledging the state's reversal in the verdict.

Origins of the Procedural Breakdown

The complex legal battle stems from an appeal filed by the state against Stattman's original acquittal. During the appeal hearings in September 2024, the justices highlighted legal difficulties regarding the sex offense charges and raised the possibility of convicting him of assault instead. In response, the state submitted a formal notification stating that after listening to the court's remarks, it was withdrawing its request to secure a conviction on sex offenses while requesting an assault conviction instead.

However, in March 2025, Justices Alex Stein, Yosef Elron, and Yehiel Kasher delivered a unanimous verdict upholding the state's appeal and convicting Stattman of rape by deception. Justice Sohlberg emphasized that the judgment completely omitted the state's unambiguous withdrawal from the original sex offense charges, triggering a severe miscommunication between the bench, the prosecution, and the defense.

Dissenting Judicial Perspectives and Ruling

While Justices Stein and Elron maintained that the conviction should stand despite the misunderstanding, Justice Kasher acknowledged that he would not have joined the conviction had he known the state's withdrawal was unconditional. Kasher explicitly stated his desire to correct his error and alter the ruling to an assault conviction.

Justice Sohlberg determined that this breakdown undermined the foundation of the conviction, noting that the ruling was issued under a mistaken assumption regarding the prosecution's true stance.

"There is neither embarrassment nor weakness in a judiciary, a human endeavor, that is willing to examine itself and respond to substantive errors and malfunctions along the way. Quite the contrary. This is the source of its strength and power."

Sohlberg ordered that the retrial take place in the Supreme Court before an expanded panel of five justices, to be appointed by Supreme Court President Isaac Amit. He stressed that the retrial decision does not determine innocence or guilt, but rather ensures judicial integrity and addresses the profound procedural flaw.

Background of the Case

The criminal proceedings originated nearly twelve years ago following an investigation into Stattman's medical practice. In December 2018, an indictment was filed accusing him of committing sex offenses during medical treatments by falsely presenting them as necessary medical procedures. The Jerusalem District Court acquitted him unanimously in December 2022, ruling that the required criminal intent had not been proven. Following the Supreme Court's subsequent decision to overturn the acquittal and convict him of rape by deception, Stattman pursued legal avenues that ultimately culminated in the current retrial order.

Related News