Double Murder Indictment Amended to Eight Years Following Plea Bargain

Billal Mugrabi received an eight-year prison sentence in the District Court after a plea bargain removed double murder charges stemming from a deadly Ramla family feud.

Double Murder Indictment Amended to Eight Years Following Plea Bargain
Photo: דוברות המשטרה

A high-profile double murder case in Ramla concluded with an eight-year prison sentence after prosecutors dropped the homicide charges as part of a plea bargain. Billal (Ben Ziad) Mugrabi, initially accused of gunning down brothers Mohammad and Walid Mugrabi last year, was convicted instead of aggravated assault and weapons offenses in the District Court.

Collapse of the Murder Case

The original indictment stated that the defendant drew his weapon and intentionally killed the two brothers following a violent dispute in the neighborhood. However, the evidentiary foundation crumbled when defense attorney Yariv Halevi successfully challenged the reliability of the prosecution's primary witnesses, 14-year-ordinate twin minors. Police had previously relocated and hidden the young witnesses due to safety concerns.

The court noted that while the main witness did her best to testify, the proceedings suffered from a lack of genuine cooperation and critical investigative hurdles. Furthermore, the defense secured crucial investigative materials only during the cross-examination of the principal witness, which severely undermined the state's reconstruction of the events.

Amended Indictment and Final Verdict

Under the amended indictment, murder charges were removed entirely. Billal Mugrabi was convicted of intentionally injuring the victims' father, Iyad Mugrabi, by shooting him in the legs after the father rushed to the scene upon hearing about the initial altercation. The revised charges cited aggravated assault, illegal weapon possession, and carrying ammunition.

"The sentence reflects an immense gap between the monstrous original accusation that our client shot the father and murdered his two minor sons before his eyes, and the actual evidence in the file," defense attorney Yariv Halevi stated. "Our client is not a murderer, and we are pleased that he has received his life back."

The District Court sentenced Billal Mugrabi to eight years of actual imprisonment, 30 months of suspended imprisonment, and ordered him to pay 250,000 shekels in compensation to Iyad Mugrabi. Two additional defendants faced judgment in the same ruling: Ali Mugrabi received an 18-month prison term and a 12-month suspended sentence for firing weapons unlawfully in a residential area, while the court ordered the immediate release of Aied Mugrabi.

Related News