Debtors Refusing to Vacate Sold Property Cannot Erase Daily Penalties

A Jerusalem court ruled that debtors who failed to vacate a sold property remain liable for daily compensation accrued after entering insolvency, bypassing discharge.

Debtors Refusing to Vacate Sold Property Cannot Erase Daily Penalties
Photo: Bahnfrend / Wikimedia Commons

A Jerusalem court has ruled that debtors who failed to vacate a property after selling their protected tenancy rights remain personally liable for daily compensation accrued after entering insolvency proceedings, rendering those specific obligations immune to a future discharge order.

Chronology of the Real Estate Dispute

The case dates back to July 2020, when a couple sold their protected tenancy rights in the property for 1.25 million shekels, with 750,000 shekels paid directly to them and 500,000 shekels allocated to the property owners. The sellers subsequently sought to cancel the agreement, and the parties reached an understanding that cancellation would be contingent on refunding the money and covering damages. Although the sellers returned 570,000 shekels to the buyers, they failed to fulfill the remaining terms of the transaction.

In May 2022, the buyers filed a lawsuit at the Jerusalem Magistrate's Court to enforce the agreement, secure an eviction order, and claim damages. Later that year, insolvency proceedings were formally initiated against the couple, though the court granted permission for the lawsuit to proceed. Judge Moria Charka subsequently ordered the eviction of the property. Following an unsuccessful appeal by the sellers, they finally vacated the premises in June 2024.

Court Rulings and Compensation Breakdown

In a subsequent ruling, the sellers were ordered to pay a liquidated penalty of 125,000 shekels alongside a daily late fee of 300 shekels accumulating from December 2020 until the actual evacuation, subject to standard linkage and interest. Additional legal expenses of 15,000 shekels were imposed on top of previous costs, with the court stipulating that 24,000 shekels previously deposited by the debtors—adjusted with linkage and interest—would be deducted from the liabilities.

Presiding over the recent financial classification dispute, Judge Ofer Yuval rejected the debtors' argument that the daily accumulation constituted a pre-existing debt subject to discharge under insolvency protection. The judge emphasized that obligations arising from continuous unlawful possession after the commencement of insolvency proceedings constitute fresh liabilities generated on a daily basis.

"The continued occupancy of the property was a choice made by the debtors, who elected to litigate and file appeals while assuming the risk that their claims would be dismissed and that the daily compensation would continue to mount," Judge Yuval stated.

Consequently, the court permitted the buyers to offset the one-time penalty and daily compensation accumulated up to September 20, 2022, from a 570,000-shekel deposit previously placed in court. The judge noted that the right of set-off serves as an exception to the principle of creditor equality because the mutual debts are legally intertwined. However, compensation accumulated after that specific date cannot be offset from the deposit and may be collected directly from the couple following the conclusion of their insolvency proceedings. The remaining balance of the deposit, after updated calculations, will be transferred to the bankruptcy liquidation fund.

Related News