City Tower Tenants Allege Hotel Shifted Private Water Bills to Shared Meter
Apartment owners and commercial tenants at Ramat Gan's City Tower claim the Leonardo City Tower hotel illegally shifted its private water bills onto shared building meters, accumulating hundreds of thousands of shekels in disputed charges.

A legal dispute has erupted over water billing at the mixed-use City Tower in Ramat Gan, where 191 apartment owners and a commercial holding firm accuse the Leonardo City Tower hotel of shifting its private water consumption onto the building's shared utility bill.
In an application for leave to appeal filed in court, the residential apartment owners alongside Shaul Shriki Holdings claim they have been saddled for years with inflated shared water bills totaling hundreds of thousands of shekels. The applicants assert that normal shared water consumption in the tower should be virtually zero because the building operates on a closed system with negligible communal water use. According to the legal filing, the excess water billed to residents is equivalent to filling multiple Olympic-sized swimming pools.
Allegations of Water Diversion and Billing Manipulation
The plaintiffs allege that the hotel, operated by the Fattal hotel chain, diverted private water usage from hundreds of guest rooms and a massive swimming pool onto the shared building meter behind the backs of other stakeholders. Furthermore, the petition claims that one of the hotel's private water meters is inoperable, leaving water consumption across several hotel floors entirely unmeasured.
Parallel to the dispute over hotel consumption, Shaul Shriki Holdings—which owns a 1% ground-floor commercial stake in the building—is contesting a requirement that holds the company responsible for 25% of the shared water consumption. The firm argues that under the building's agreed bylaws, its share should be strictly 1%. It is seeking to overturn a 2019 court ruling on the matter, which it claims was issued without its knowledge or participation.
Current Legal Proceedings and Stakeholder Responses
The current appeal to the District Court focuses on interim decisions made by the Magistrate's Court in an ongoing lawsuit, specifically challenging the appointment of a court expert whose mandate allegedly excludes investigating the suspected water diversion by the hotel. The applicants also argue that the lower court improperly barred them from submitting independent expert opinions to substantiate their claims, while asking to suspend the expert's work pending the appeal.
City Tower is a mixed-use skyscraper divided into five distinct wings: residential apartments occupy 31% of the space with 208 units across eight floors; the Leonardo City Tower hotel spans 11 floors, accounting for 30% of the property; an event hall wing controlled by Fattal occupies three floors representing 11%; a five-story parking garage owned by REIT 1 accounts for 27%; and the ground-floor commercial center constitutes the remaining 1%.
Responding to the allegations, the Fattal chain stated that the issue has already been litigated and resolved in the past. The company maintained that the hotel operates in full compliance with the law and previous rulings, and expressed confidence that the current judicial review will reaffirm its position.





