Ayalon Highways Director Faces Conflict Scrutiny Over Solel Boneh Case

Adv. Michal Saar, a director at state-owned Ayalon Highways, faces scrutiny after representing contractor Solel Boneh in a legal dispute without prior conflict clearance.

Ayalon Highways Director Faces Conflict Scrutiny Over Solel Boneh Case
Photo-illustration WireIsrael: AI Generated

A potential conflict of interest involving Adv. Michal Saar, a newly appointed director and audit committee chair at the state-owned Ayalon Highways company, has come to light following her legal representation of Shikun & Binui subsidiary Solel Boneh. Saar was appointed to the board of Ayalon Highways in July 2025 while maintaining an active private law practice specializing in planning, construction, licensing, litigation, and local authorities.

On September 22, 2025, Saar filed an administrative petition on behalf of Solel Boneh against the Tel Aviv Municipality and Mayor Ron Huldai regarding a demolition and construction project at Ichilov Hospital. Five days later, on September 27 during the Sukkot holiday, Saar approached the legal counsel of Ayalon Highways to inquire whether her representation of Solel Boneh posed a conflict of interest given her board position.

Ayalon Highways operates as an executive arm of the Ministry of Transport, managing an annual tender volume estimated between 2 billion and 3 billion shekels out of a total order backlog of approximately 19.6 billion shekels. Publicly available documents indicate that Solel Boneh maintains a close business relationship with Ayalon Highways as a contractor, executing electrical, communication, traffic light, closed-circuit television camera, and travel time measurement system projects.

Representatives for Solel Boneh noted that Saar serves as an external consultant to the firm. Saar maintains that she initiated contact with Ayalon Highways' legal department independently and was unaware of any existing business ties between the two entities when she accepted the case. She also emphasized that she has never been involved in selecting Solel Boneh as a supplier, nor has the company's name ever been raised in board meetings she attended.

The timing of the inquiry has drawn scrutiny, arriving after the legal petition was already filed and during a holiday period. The situation unfolds amid broader turbulence at Ayalon Highways, following the departure of former board chair Idan David, who faced an investigation by Lahav 433 over alleged falsification of credentials and inflated budget data. Additionally, the State Comptroller is actively examining conflict of interest issues across the company.

As of early October 2025, Ayalon Highways' legal counsel stated the matter remains under review, and Saar has not yet received a formal determination. In response, Saar has sought further guidance from the Government Companies Authority regarding the interpretation of Attorney General Directive 6.5000 concerning lawyers serving on corporate boards. Ayalon Highways confirmed that Saar reported her representation on September 27 and that the issue is being evaluated according to standard procedures.

Related News