Israeli Red Food Labels Outperform European Nutri-Score in Eye-Tracking Study
A study by Hebrew University and German researchers shows Israel's red food warning labels outperform Europe's Nutri-Score in catching attention and guiding healthy choices.

A recent joint study conducted by the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and Germany's University of Hohenheim reveals that Israel's bold red warning labels on food packaging are more effective at capturing consumer attention and conveying health messages than Europe's Nutri-Score system. Utilizing eye-tracking technology, researchers tracked the visual focus and behavioral responses of 223 participants split evenly between Germany and Israel.
Comparing Front-of-Package Systems
The European Nutri-Score system, launched in 2017 and adopted by countries including France, Belgium, the Netherlands, and Germany, uses a five-tier color-coded scale ranging from dark green "A" to red "E". The algorithm balances negative nutritional values such as calories, saturated fats, sugars, and sodium against positive attributes like fiber, protein, and fruit content. While this grading helps consumers compare products within the same category, critics note it can allow industrial food "whitening," where manufacturers add protein or fiber to offset high sodium or sugar levels.
In contrast, Israel mandates explicit red warning labels on packaged foods exceeding specific thresholds: more than 10 grams of sugar, 400 milligrams of sodium, or 4 grams of saturated fat per 100 grams for solid foods. Liquid items are restricted to 5 grams of sugar, 300 milligrams of sodium, or 3 sterile grams of saturated fat per 100 milliliters. These labels do not allow nutrient offsetting, ensuring that a product high in sodium receives an immediate red sticker regardless of its fiber content. Alongside warning labels, Israel utilizes a voluntary green label for healthier whole foods.
Eye-Tracking Insights and Psychological Impact
During the laboratory experiment, participants viewed simulated food packages bearing either Nutri-Score markings or the Israeli red warning and green verification labels while researchers monitored their gaze duration and visual fixation. Afterward, participants rated the perceived healthiness, taste, and purchase intent of the items.
Findings demonstrated a clear preference for the Israeli system across both nationalities:
-
Participants from both Israel and Germany rated the Israeli warning labels as easier to understand and more helpful for making healthy nutritional decisions compared to Nutri-Score.
-
Products displaying explicit red warning labels triggered more critical and rigorous evaluations than the exact same products presented with Nutri-Score ratings, which tended to elicit milder, more forgiving assessments.
-
Consumers quickly identified familiar domestic labels but spent significantly more visual time processing unfamiliar systems, yet still concluded that the Israeli warning labels offered superior clarity.
Policy Implications and Study Limitations
As regulatory institutions across the European Union debate mandatory uniform front-of-package labeling, and the US Food and Drug Administration advances proposals for front-of-package nutritional tier boxes, researchers emphasize that public health interventions must rely on rigorous empirical evidence regarding human psychological response.
At the same time, the study's authors acknowledged several methodological limitations. The research relied on a laboratory sample of 223 participants, omitting real-world shopping distractions such as pricing, promotions, and store environments. Furthermore, the study measured visual attention rather than long-term dietary consumption changes, leaving open the question of whether red warning labels sustainably alter purchasing habits over extended periods.





