Former Shin Bet Chief Ami Ayalon Warns Government Policies Threaten Democracy

Former Shin Bet chief Ami Ayalon warned that government policies marginalizing Arab citizens threaten Israeli democracy and security, citing severe crises of public trust and historical lessons.

Former Shin Bet Chief Ami Ayalon Warns Government Policies Threaten Democracy
Photo: Israel Security Agency (ISA / Shabak) / Wikimedia Commons

Former Shin Bet / Shabak Director Ami Ayalon issued a sharp critique against the government and domestic security leadership, warning that exclusionary policies threaten Israeli democracy and public safety. Speaking at the Palmach Museum in Tel Aviv during the launch of Dr. Amir Gilat's book "Adam Adam Adamah," Ayalon cautioned that current state practices marginalize the Arab minority and undermine foundational democratic institutions.

Ayalon invoked the findings of the Shamgar Commission, which investigated the assassination of Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, to warn against the political stigmatization of legitimate communities. He argued that when security agencies engage in actions that exclude citizens wishing to participate in the political process, they deal a severe blow to democratic norms. Pointing to government policies, Ayalon asserted that the current administration has embraced a nationalist ideology echoing the positions associated with Rabbi Meir Kahane. He referenced the 2017 policy document published by Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, stating it reflects official approaches toward Arab citizens inside Israel and across Judea and Samaria.

Security Risks of Political Exclusion

The former intelligence chief drew upon his decades of military and security experience, warning that systemic disenfranchisement breeds violent radicalization. Drawing a parallel to the period preceding the Second Intifada, Ayalon stated that eroding trust in state authorities and blocking avenues for legitimate political integration inevitably fuel unrest and lawlessness. He cited data from a 2026 Israel Democracy Institute survey indicating a deep crisis of confidence, with only 7 percent of Arab citizens expressing trust in the government and just 5 percent trusting the Prime Minister.

Conversely, the survey data highlights that roughly 75 percent of the Arab public supports the integration of Arab parties into governance, while 71 percent of the Jewish public opposes including Arab factions in coalitions. Ayalon dismissed claims that high voter turnout among Arab citizens stemmed from local violence, attributing participation instead to legitimate grievances and a desire for equal rights. He also referenced the Or Commission report from 2000, arguing that Israeli officialdom has failed to fully internalize the equal citizenship of the Arab minority.

Concluding his address, Ayalon called upon civil society to uphold the vision of equality enshrined in the Declaration of Independence. He urged the public to embrace an inclusive form of Judaism grounded in human dignity and social justice, emphasizing that national security and democratic identity depend entirely on granting equal partnership to all citizens.

Related News