Amazon Faces Scrutiny Over Black Friday Discounts as Study Sparks Controversy

Amazon faces criticism from a new study alleging that nearly 30% of its promotional items during Black Friday lacked genuine discounts. The e-commerce giant strongly rejects the findings, citing massive sample discrepancies and defending its pricing accuracy.

Amazon Faces Scrutiny Over Black Friday Discounts as Study Sparks Controversy
Photo: Unsplash / Tamanna Rumee

Days before the launch of major shopping events, Amazon is facing intense scrutiny following a new study that questions the authenticity of its promotional discounts. The research, published by the Groundwork Collaborative, examines the pricing of 351 products promoted by Amazon during Black Friday and Cyber Monday events across 2024 and 2025. According to the findings, 29.1% of the analyzed items were sold during the promotional events at prices equal to or higher than the lowest price offered in the 30 days preceding the sales.

Furthermore, the researchers claim that in 9.4% of cases, the event price actually exceeded the lowest price recorded during the previous month. Among the specific examples cited are men's UGG boots, which were listed during Cyber Monday 2025 at $179.98, despite being available for $98.40 approximately four weeks earlier. The study also highlights Hunter rain boots that allegedly sold on Black Friday for $126.99, compared to $79.97 just nine days prior to the event.

Amazon Rejects Findings and Questions Methodology

Amazon strongly rejects the study's conclusions, issuing a sharp rebuttal that defends its pricing integrity. An internal analysis conducted by the company indicates that 98% of the products referenced in the study were sold during the shopping events at prices equal to or lower than their rates from the preceding 30 days, with the figure rising to 99% for 2025 products specifically.

Beyond challenging the figures, Amazon questions the study's sample size, noting that the platform featured more than 10 million deals during the examined shopping events, whereas the final research relied on a sample of only about 350 items. The e-commerce giant emphasizes that just 17 of its top 200 best-selling promotions were included in the evaluation.

Revisions and Future Safeguards

Amazon further discloses that the research underwent significant alterations prior to publication. According to the company, an early draft circulated to media outlets encompassed nearly 1,500 products from 2025 and 2026 events. After the company pointed out alleged errors in the data and methodology, publication was delayed, 2026 data was removed, and the sample was reduced while incorporating 2024 figures.

The company also notes that certain products evaluated in the research were never officially designated or marked as deals on the platform, admitting that a small number of items were mistakenly presented as promotions in a company blog post. Meanwhile, the Groundwork Collaborative stands by its research, maintaining that even after adjusting for various price fluctuations, roughly one-fifth of the analyzed items offered no actual savings during the promotional window. Amazon concludes by highlighting its consumer tools, including Alexa-powered price history tracking and drop alerts for shoppers.

Related News