Tel Aviv Court Orders 11 Million Shekel Payout Over Missed Prenatal Findings

The Tel Aviv District Court ordered Sheba and Wolfson hospitals and Meuhedet Health Services to pay 11 million shekels to parents after failing to report critical prenatal findings.

Tel Aviv Court Orders 11 Million Shekel Payout Over Missed Prenatal Findings
Photo: Nizzan Cohen / Wikimedia Commons

The Tel Aviv District Court ordered medical institutions to pay 11 million shekels in compensation to parents whose son was born with a severe genetic defect causing cognitive disability and permanent impairment. Judge Orna Levi ruled that medical teams at Sheba Medical Center, Wolfson Medical Center, and Meuhedet Health Services failed to properly alert the parents to alarming prenatal findings, depriving them of the opportunity to make an informed decision regarding the continuation of the pregnancy.

The case dates back to 2011, when the mother received prenatal care through Meuhedet Health Services. During the 26th week of pregnancy, a community physician referred her to the emergency department and an ultrasound scan following suspected fluid accumulation around the fetal heart. Admitted to Wolfson Medical Center, she underwent anatomical surveys and secondary evaluations. Although medical records indicated a recommendation for genetic counseling, the primary care physician failed to provide the necessary referral.

Clinical Oversight and Missed Red Flags

As the pregnancy progressed, additional complications emerged, including abnormal fluid accumulation around one of the fetal lungs and measurements indicating smaller than expected head and abdominal circumferences. The patient was referred to Sheba Medical Center for fluid drainage and subsequent monitoring. During labor, which spanned several days, further abnormalities were documented, prompting genetic counseling at Sheba. Two summary documents from this consultation were filed without being shared with the parents in real time, and the mother ultimately underwent an emergency cesarean section. The newborn required mechanical ventilation and now suffers from permanent brain impairment, requiring round-the-clock care.

In her ruling, Judge Levi criticized the lack of coordination among the treating entities, noting that the clinical picture was missed and the patient fell between the cracks. She emphasized that Wolfson Medical Center failed to recommend a fetal MRI despite concerning indicators, and pointed out that the importance of a comprehensive genetic chip test was never adequately explained to the parents. Furthermore, the court questioned the reliability of genetic consultation documents produced by Sheba Medical Center, suggesting they were compiled retrospectively rather than contemporaneously.

Compensation and Institutional Responses

Accounting for deductions such as prior settlements with Meuhedet Health Services and future allowances from the National Insurance Institute, the state-owned Sheba and Wolfson hospitals are slated to pay approximately 7 million shekels. The court also awarded 260,000 shekels specifically for the violation of the parents' reproductive autonomy.

Attorneys Yisrael Weinberg and Shiri Chasidov Perag, representing the plaintiffs, stated that the ruling followed eight years of intensive litigation involving thorough cross-examinations of senior medical experts. Wolfson Medical Center announced it would review the decision in depth, while Sheba Medical Center stated its intention to appeal, maintaining that the patient arrived late in pregnancy and was repeatedly advised to expand genetic testing but chose to continue the pregnancy.

"We are well aware of the complexity and pain involved in coping with the birth of a child with a disability. Advanced genetic testing is a significant tool in diagnosing findings during pregnancy, and we offered the patient further genetic evaluation and the option of a termination committee, which she declined," Sheba Medical Center representatives remarked in their official response.

Related News