Israeli Retail Leaders Clash Over Smart Carts and Supplier Pricing Power
Israeli retail executives debated smart cart technology, supplier pricing power, and regulatory pressures at the Israfood conference, addressing consumer costs and retail friction.

Leading figures in Israel's retail grocery sector gathered at the 41st Israfood exhibition, hosted by the Stier Group at the "Between Shelf and Screen" food retail conference, to debate the integration of store technology, public perception of the cost of living, and the tightening grip of antitrust regulations.
Smart Carts and Self-Checkout: Innovation or Theft Risk?
A sharp division emerged among retail executives regarding the rollout of in-store automation, such as smart shopping carts and self-service checkouts. Eyal Ravid, CEO and owner of the Victory supermarket chain, voiced severe skepticism about these technologies, characterizing them as vulnerable to consumer misuse.
"When people in Israel talk about technology, they usually mean smart carts or self-checkouts. I call all of this the 'thief sector'," Ravid stated during the panel discussion. He argued that shoppers frequently exploit cart scanners by scanning low-priced items while placing much more expensive goods into the basket without adequate weight verification or cashier oversight, leaving stores vulnerable to substantial inventory shrinkage.
Conversely, Oren Sapir, CEO and owner of Super Sapir and Neto Hisachon, defended the deployment of automation, reporting excellent results from his retail branches over a two-year operational period. Sapir emphasized that technology is indispensable for maintaining competitiveness and enhancing customer convenience.
"The technology makes us more competitive and allows us to offer lower prices. Anyone who fails to adopt these systems will not survive in a few years," Sapir asserted, noting that shrinkage rates remain low despite rapid transaction speeds.
Supplier Dominance Versus Retailer Blame
The discussion also focused on the disconnect between the public image of supermarket chains and the commercial reality dictated by major manufacturers and food importers. The panelists concurred that retailers absorb unwarranted public criticism because they are the sole entities interacting directly with consumers at the checkout counter.
Ravid pointed out that major suppliers and brand manufacturers dictate the underlying product costs, noting that even private-label goods ultimately rely on external or internal manufacturing plants. However, he observed that modern consumers have become increasingly discerning, scrutinizing packaging labels and nutritional values while gradually recognizing that suppliers hold ultimate pricing power.
Antitrust Enforcement and Regulatory Shifts
The retail panel unfolded against the backdrop of heightened regulatory scrutiny following the Israel Competition Authority's February 2025 indictment against Victory, Ravid, and senior executives from Yochananof and Super Bareket. The charges allege violations of the Competition Law and the Food Law, including attempts to signal price increases through public remarks and coordinating promotional activities.
Although participants did not directly address the ongoing legal proceedings, the conversation reflected a transformed commercial landscape. Shalom Neeman, co-CEO and owner of Mahsanei Hashuk, explained that increased oversight by the competition commissioner has forced chains to operate with greater professional caution, reduce their reliance on dominant suppliers, and expand parallel imports.
"Today, the focus is on parallel importation to avoid relying heavily on a single dominant supplier. It forces a retail chain to become more professional and competitive," Neeman said. Furthermore, executives underscored strict legal limits regarding data sharing, noting that any commercial data exchange with suppliers must go through regulated third-party entities, while real-time price comparison websites have made competitor tracking entirely transparent.
Criticism of Cost-of-Living Media Coverage
Concluding the conference, the executives criticized how the Israeli media covers food inflation and retail pricing. Ravid argued that supermarkets face disproportionate public scrutiny compared to other profitable financial sectors.
"Consumers are hit twenty times a month with headlines about supermarket chains, while a bank generates billions in quarterly profit and receives a headline once every two months. A massive amount of money flows there without equivalent consumer service, which makes no sense and feels like a spin," Ravid stated.
Sapir and Neeman added that today's consumers carefully track every shekel and arrive at stores fully informed by digital price comparison tools, leaving retailers with the core obligation to deliver efficient service, quality shopping experiences, and reasonable price points.





