German Politician Michael Roth Warns of Growing Leftist Antagonism Against Israel
Former German official Michael Roth warns that SPD politicians increasingly hide pro-Israel views due to electoral calculus and leftist ideological shifts following October 7.

Michael Roth, former Chairman of the German Bundestag Foreign Affairs Committee and former Minister of State for Europe, warns of a growing reluctance among Social Democratic Party (SPD) politicians to voice support for Israel. Ahead of his participation in the ELNET conference in Jerusalem, Roth highlights how shifting political dynamics within Germany's ruling coalition have complicated public solidarity with the Jewish state.
The Shift Within the German Left
Reflecting on the atmosphere following the October 7 Hamas massacres, Roth notes that political sympathy eroded rapidly. He points to an increasingly dominant simplistic post-colonial ideology within the European left that divides the world rigidly into oppressors and victims, persistently casting Israel in a negative light. Furthermore, electoral calculus plays a role, with some politicians viewing the Jewish community as a very small demographic compared to larger immigrant constituencies.
"They are sharing these views quietly because speaking up for Israel has become a difficult task in my party. The mood on the left has shifted, and some politicians simply do calculations: Jews are a very small voter group in Germany, and other groups with a migration background are much larger."
Despite facing personal estrangement from former colleagues and occasional verbal harassment on the streets, Roth maintains that Israel retains a broad base of support in Germany that transcends loud public arguments.
Separating Government Policy and State Support
Roth draws a clear distinction between criticizing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's administration and abandoning support for Israel as a democratic nation. While he acknowledges his own opposition to Netanyahu's policies and argues that the Israeli leader has failed to counter negative international perceptions, Roth condemns the dangerous blurring of lines where critics transfer responsibility for Israeli government actions onto German Jews.
At the same time, Roth appeals to Israeli leadership to avoid alienating international allies. He emphasizes that settler violence against Palestinians and debates surrounding capital punishment severely undermine Israel's standing among critical friends in Europe and the United States.
Fostering Realism in Berlin
Looking toward his return to Berlin, Roth stresses the necessity of bringing a dose of realism back to German political discourse. He cautions against the naive assumption among many German observers that a change in Israel's leadership alone would instantly resolve complex regional security challenges.
"Germans many times hope that everything will be much better once Mr. Netanyahu leaves office. I hope so too. But Israelis want security and peace without terror, and therefore the fight against Hamas and other terrorist organizations will continue, no matter who is at the head of the government," Roth concludes.





