US Envoys Float NATO Membership for Ukraine in Exchange for Territorial Concessions

US envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff have reportedly proposed offering Ukraine NATO membership in exchange for territorial concessions to Russia, sparking intense debate among European leaders and Kyiv.

US Envoys Float NATO Membership for Ukraine in Exchange for Territorial Concessions
Photo: Tony Webster / Wikimedia Commons

In closed-door peace talks held over recent months, representatives of US President Donald Trump, Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, have floated a proposal linking Ukrainian NATO membership to territorial concessions to Russia, as reported by local media.

According to sources familiar with the negotiations, the initiative was discussed in several meetings between Kushner, Witkoff, and European officials. The proposal was also raised during a meeting with President Volodymyr Zelensky at a military base in Dublin and in subsequent discussions in the United Arab Emirates.

Two Scenarios for Ending the Conflict

The US administration presented two potential pathways for ending the war. The first scenario requires Kyiv to relinquish the remaining territories under its control in the eastern Donbas region in exchange for full NATO membership. The second scenario proposes freezing the conflict along the current frontline while providing Ukraine with security guarantees through an international treaty involving the United States and European allies.

This initiative marks a potential shift in American policy, given that Trump had previously dismissed the possibility of Ukraine joining the military alliance. During a meeting in Berlin with nations supporting Ukraine, Kushner stated that Moscow has begun to feel comfortable with the concept of security guarantees resembling those of NATO.

Stakeholder Positions and Russian Demands

President Zelensky confirmed that the American side raised the possibility during recent discussions. Speaking to reporters, Zelensky noted that the US side inquired about potential scenarios involving NATO membership and a withdrawal from the Donbas. However, the Ukrainian leader emphasized that any agreement would require the approval of the Ukrainian people and stressed that his country does not yield its land.

In contrast, Russia maintained a rigid stance during discussions held in Abu Dhabi. According to an unofficial document circulated among participants, Moscow demanded that Ukraine remove any aspirations for NATO membership from its constitution, halt Western arms shipments to Kyiv, and roll back the alliance's military infrastructure in Eastern Europe to 1997 levels.

European leaders remain sharply divided over the proposal. While French President Emmanuel Macron stated following the Berlin meeting that the time has come to discuss Ukrainian membership in NATO, German Federal Chancellor Friedrich Merz expressed a firm stance to associates that Ukraine will not join the alliance in the near future.

Related News