Israel Railways Ordered to Pay Legal Fees Over Delayed Expropriation Funds

Israel Railways must pay 120,000 shekels in legal costs after the Haifa District Court ruled it delayed expropriation compensation for land needed to expand the Coastal Railway.

Israel Railways Ordered to Pay Legal Fees Over Delayed Expropriation Funds
Photo: Nizzan Cohen / Wikimedia Commons

Israel Railways has been ordered to pay 120,000 shekels plus VAT to the moshav of Beit Hanania after missing statutory deadlines for land expropriation compensation tied to the Coastal Railway expansion project.

Court Rules on Statutory Timelines

Presiding at the District Court in Haifa, Judge Saji Ghawi ruled that Israel Railways breached the law by failing to disburse undisputed compensation within 90 days of taking possession of the land. The court dismissed the company's defense that it had acted in accordance with legal requirements.

The legal dispute originated in March 2024, when Israel Railways issued expropriation notices for agricultural lands belonging to the Beit Hanania cooperative as part of a major initiative to upgrade the Coastal Railway between Hof HaCarmel and Shefayim. The railway company took formal possession of the plots in June 2025, triggering a strict 90-day statutory window to transfer compensation.

Disputed Deadlines and Payments

When the deadline passed without payment, the cooperative filed a lawsuit in January 2026. Approximately two months after the legal action commenced, Israel Railways transferred roughly 6.9 million shekels to the moshav, though a sharp disagreement persisted regarding interest and legal expenses.

The moshav argued that the remittance arrived 156 days late, noting that the railway company was well aware of its land rights. The cooperative presented a rights certificate obtained from the Israel Land Authority in August 2025 and pointed out that the railway's own appraiser had recognized its ownership status. Furthermore, Israel Railways had already paid the moshav approximately 800,000 shekels for relocating water infrastructure.

Conversely, Israel Railways maintained that it did not delay the payment. It claimed that the moshav's lease contract with the Israel Land Authority had expired in 2014, requiring an updated rights verification that was only delivered in December 2025. The company argued that the 90-day countdown should begin from that date and accused the plaintiff of acting in bad faith to generate excessive legal fees.

Ruling on Legal Costs

Judge Ghawi rejected the railway's arguments, emphasizing that the law mandates compensation within 90 days of taking possession rather than upon the receipt of updated paperwork. The court noted that the legislature established a rigid framework to prevent undue delays in compensating landowners.

While the court upheld the legitimacy of the lawsuit for compelling the payout, it denied the moshav's request for punitive default interest, finding that the governing expropriation framework did not permit such additional charges in this specific case. Regarding legal representation, the judge dismissed the moshav's demand for a fee of up to 1.5 million shekels—representing ten percent of the compensation—as disproportionate and astronomical, given that the proceedings concluded early without a formal defense or courtroom hearings. Consequently, the court ordered Israel Railways to cover 120,000 shekels plus VAT in legal fees and reimburse the filing fee.

Related News