Haifa Municipality Ordered to Pay Damages for Sidewalk Injury Accident

The Haifa Municipality was ordered to pay compensation to an Israel Electric Corporation worker who suffered permanent injury after falling into a hazardous sidewalk hole in December 2018.

Haifa Municipality Ordered to Pay Damages for Sidewalk Injury Accident
Photo: Yakovleva / Wikimedia Commons

The Haifa Municipality has been ordered to pay compensation following a lawsuit filed by a 54-year-old Israel Electric Corporation employee who was injured after stepping into a hazardous hole on a broken sidewalk. The ruling was recently handed down by the Magistrate's Court in Haifa, concluding a legal battle over an accident that occurred in December 2018 in the city's Hof Shemen industrial area.

Accident Circumstances and Court Findings

The incident took place when the worker arrived at the company's garage in a work vehicle and found the adjacent intersection blocked by heavy trucks. He stepped out of his car to assist in directing traffic and clearing the road. While walking along the pedestrian walkway, his foot plunged into a deep hole filled with rainwater and gravel, causing him to lose his balance and fall heavily onto his leg and shoulders.

Presiding Judge Tali Mirom accepted the plaintiff's version of events, supported by photographs of the damaged pavement, a digital messaging record sent on the day of the incident, and security camera footage. The court determined that the municipality failed in its duty to maintain the sidewalk and remove a severe safety hazard located near a pedestrian crossing. However, the judge assigned 10% contributory negligence to the worker, noting that he should have exercised heightened caution while walking in rainy weather conditions.

Compensation and Medical Assessment

The court-appointed medical expert determined that the plaintiff sustained a 10% permanent disability in his right shoulder, while rejecting a claim linking his left shoulder injury to the accident. Although the worker claimed he was forced to retire early from his position at the Israel Electric Corporation due to the trauma, the judge dismissed this assertion due to a lack of occupational physician certification.

The total damages were assessed at 207,500 shekels, encompassing 140,000 shekels for lost earning capacity, 40,000 shekels for pain and suffering, and the remainder for pension losses, assistance, and expenses. After deducting the 10% for contributory negligence, the net compensation was set at 186,750 shekels. Because the plaintiff had already received 299,308 shekels in benefits from the National Insurance Institute, the municipality was ordered to pay a remaining balance of 46,688 shekels, alongside 11,018 shekels in legal fees and court expenses.

Related News