Grand Theft Auto 6 Hit by Metacritic Review Bombing Amid Fan Wars

Grand Theft Auto 6 faces a massive review bombing campaign on Metacritic, dropping its user score to 5 while verified store ratings remain stellar at nearly 5 out of 5.

Grand Theft Auto 6 Hit by Metacritic Review Bombing Amid Fan Wars
Photo: Take-Two Interactive / Wikimedia Commons

Grand Theft Auto 6 has encountered a massive wave of negative user reviews on Metacritic just days after its historic launch, dragging its user score down to around 5 out of 10 despite a near-perfect 99 from professional critics. The game, developed by Rockstar, generated a staggering 3.79 billion dollars in revenue on its opening day alone.

By Saturday morning, over 34,000 user ratings had flooded the platform, with many submitting a flat zero. Industry analysts and media reports indicate this is a textbook case of review bombing, where users flood a title with negative scores to protest or harm its reputation. Forbes and other tech outlets revealed that some reviews even contained leftover artificial intelligence prompt instructions and admissions from users who admitted they had never played the game.

Technical Complaints and Fan Wars

While many negative reviews stem from automated bots or malicious actors, legitimate players have voiced grievances regarding game performance and design choices. Prominent complaints focus on the title being locked at 30 frames per second on consoles without a 60 frames per second mode, even on high-end PlayStation 5 Pro hardware. Other critics targeted narrative choices, claiming the plot focuses too heavily on relationships between protagonists Jason and Lucia rather than traditional criminal activities, while some reviews featured misogynistic and racist remarks.

The review bombing quickly spilled over into a full-scale fan war affecting The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. Believing Nintendo fans were behind the sabotage of GTA 6, retaliatory reviewers began review-bombing the Zelda remake, causing its user score to plummet from 9.6 to 8.7 out of 10 on Metacritic. The rivalry centers on historical rankings, as GTA 6 tied the original 1998 Zelda title's legendary 99 critic score.

Divergent Scores Across Platforms

Despite the turmoil on Metacritic, verified buyer reviews on official console storefronts present an entirely different reality. On the PlayStation Store, where ratings require an actual purchase, GTA 6 secured a stellar 4.84 out of 5 from roughly 170,000 ratings, with a similarly high 4.9 recorded on the Xbox store. Because Metacritic allows unverified registrations without proof of purchase, it remains vulnerable to manipulation, though the commercial powerhouse status of Rockstar ensures the controversy will not dampen its unprecedented market success.

Related News