Tel Aviv Court Approves Class Action Against Dairy Giants Over Cream Labeling

Tel Aviv District Court approved a class action against Tnuva, Strauss, and Yotvata over alleged cream labeling deception, while a separate spam lawsuit against KSP was dismissed.

Tel Aviv Court Approves Class Action Against Dairy Giants Over Cream Labeling
Photo: Nizzan Cohen / Wikimedia Commons

A class action lawsuit has been approved by the Tel Aviv District Court against major Israeli dairy producers Tnuva, Strauss Group, and Yotvata Dairies over allegations of consumer deception regarding cream labeling and pricing. The legal action centers on claims that companies market 38% fat cream under the heading "whipping cream" while lower-fat variants are designated as "cooking cream", creating a misleading distinction that steers consumers toward higher-priced options.

According to court documents, the plaintiff Ori Mann argued that labeling 38% fat cream exclusively for whipping creates the impression that the regulated staple is unsuitable for culinary dishes like pasta and sauces. Consequently, shoppers seeking ingredients for cooked meals often select more expensive cooking creams rather than the price-regulated whipping cream. The 250-milliliter package of 38% whipping cream is sold at a regulated price of 7.64 shekels, whereas cooking creams containing 9%, 10%, or 15% fat range from 8.90 to 11 shekels for the same quantity.

Legal Arguments and Court Decision

The dairy manufacturers defended their packaging, arguing that the term "whipping cream" describes a common usage without precluding other culinary applications and that labels are not required to list every possible recipe. They also emphasized that the products differ in fat content, flavor, and texture. During the proceedings, Yotvata added a note to its 38% cream packaging indicating it is suitable for both cooking and baking.

Judge Noa Grossman ruled that there is a reasonable possibility the labeling and product presentation could mislead consumers. She stressed that shoppers evaluate products based on the overall impression at the supermarket shelf rather than conducting complex comparative analysis. The plaintiff estimated cumulative consumer damages at approximately 35 million shekels, divided into 27 million shekels concerning Tnuva products and 8 million shekels for Yotvata items. The court recommended that the parties return to mediation after a previous attempt failed, and Tnuva, Yotvata, and Strauss declined to comment on the ruling.

In a separate legal development, the Tel Aviv District Court dismissed a class action lawsuit seeking over 2.5 million shekels against the retail chain KSP regarding alleged spam text messages. The court ordered petitioner Attorney Amit Zilberg to pay 50,000 shekels in legal costs to KSP. The litigation revealed that a software bug caused the transmission of approximately 50,000 promotional messages in August 2020 to recipients who had not consented. However, the court found that KSP promptly identified and rectified the technical glitch, concluding there was no systemic policy of violating the law. The petitioner announced intentions to appeal the decision.

Related News