Parents Sue Clalit for 1.4 Million Shekels Over Permanent Hearing Loss

Parents of a 13-year-old girl file a 1.4 million shekel malpractice lawsuit against Clalit Health Services and an ear specialist, alleging permanent hearing loss due to delayed cyst diagnosis.

Parents Sue Clalit for 1.4 Million Shekels Over Permanent Hearing Loss
Photo-illustration WireIsrael: AI Generated

The parents of a 13-year-old girl have filed a 1.4 million shekel medical malpractice lawsuit against Clalit Health Services and an ear, nose, and throat specialist. The legal action alleges sustained negligence over a two-year period in diagnosing an ear cyst known as cholesteatoma, resulting in permanent severe hearing loss.

According to the claim filed by attorneys Dr. Assaf Posner, Gilad Lesser, and Michael Lemberger, the young patient suffered from recurrent ear infections, language difficulties, and hearing impairments from an early age. At age four, she underwent surgery on her right ear, which failed to improve her hearing. Over the following two years, she was examined at least five times by the defendant physician, who allegedly prescribed only ear drops and recommended continued monitoring instead of ordering advanced imaging scans such as CT or MRI, or referring her to a specialized pediatric otolaryngology center.

Diagnosis and Surgical Intervention

Frustrated by the lack of progress, the family independently consulted a specialist at Shaare Zedek, who immediately ordered CT and MRI scans. The imaging confirmed the presence of an ear cyst. Although surgeons removed the growth, the disease had already severely damaged the auditory structure, requiring the implantation of an artificial prosthesis.

Medical opinions submitted with the lawsuit indicate that the girl suffers from high-percentage disabilities. An ear, nose, and throat expert warned of the risk of further hearing deterioration, potentially leading to total deafness, and noted a high probability of future surgeries. A speech-language pathologist's assessment highlighted severe difficulties in speech comprehension against background noise, limited vocabulary, and memory deficits.

The plaintiffs are seeking compensation covering 150,000 shekels in medical and treatment expenses, 200,000 shekels for family care and assistance, and approximately 70,000 shekels for professional medical opinions. In addition, the family demands one million shekels in punitive damages, citing what they describe as prolonged negligence that could have been prevented through simple diagnostic tests.

In response to the legal filing, Clalit Health Services stated that the formal complaint has not yet been received, and a detailed response will be submitted through the appropriate legal channels.

Related News