Supreme Court Rules WhatsApp Message Fails to Form Binding Property Contract

The Supreme Court ruled that a WhatsApp message promising a penthouse apartment did not constitute a binding contract, reversing a lower court decision and tightening gift standards.

Supreme Court Rules WhatsApp Message Fails to Form Binding Property Contract
Photo: israeltourism / Wikimedia Commons

The Supreme Court has overturned a District Court ruling and canceled the transfer of a penthouse apartment from a former partner, ruling that a WhatsApp message did not prove serious intent to create a binding contract.

This decision aligns with a broader recent judicial trend favoring stricter adherence to formal contractual requirements. The court described the text message as laconic and lacking crucial details that would indicate the appellant's seriousness and definitive intent to transfer property rights to the respondent.

Background of the Property Dispute

The parties maintained a relationship for approximately two decades and raised two children together. Following their separation, the woman filed a lawsuit claiming entitlement to half of the assets accumulated during their shared life under the presumption of asset sharing. The man countered that the couple had maintained a regime of complete financial separation throughout their relationship.

Alongside evaluating the intent to share assets based on a handwritten note, the District Court had previously ordered the man to transfer the penthouse apartment to the respondent. That ruling relied on a WhatsApp message in which the man wrote that he had long wanted to tell her the penthouse would be registered in her name once finished. The District Court deemed the message a binding written commitment satisfying the legal requirements of intent and specificity, noting it was sent after the separation when circumstances were clear.

Supreme Court Rationale and Gift Law

The Supreme Court reversed the decision on multiple grounds. First, the bench established that even if the message constituted a valid commitment, it represented a promise to make a gift. Under Israeli law, a donor may revoke a gift promise as long as the recipient has not altered their position in reliance upon it. The court found no evidence that the respondent altered her position to her detriment, and concluded the man lawfully revoked the pledge.

The court further clarified that a donor is not legally required to provide explicit written notice of revocation to the recipient. The initiation of legal proceedings clearly demonstrated the man's refusal to gift the property, functioning as an effective retraction.

Second, the justices ruled that the WhatsApp message failed to express the requisite definitive intent needed to finalize a binding agreement. Property gifts demand a heightened standard of proof regarding intent to ensure the asset is transferred voluntarily and with full comprehension. The court emphasized that ambiguities within the text regarding essential terms presented severe deficiencies in specificity, directly undermining the existence of contractual intent.

Related News