Security Veterans Warn Rising West Bank Violence Risks Igniting Civil War
Commanders for Israel's Security warned that escalating violence and calls for independent armed groups risk triggering a civil war, urging urgent intervention from state defense leaders.

The organization "Commanders for Israel's Security" warned that mounting violence against Palestinians and calls for independent armed groups risk igniting a civil war in Israel and the West Bank. In an urgent letter dispatched to key defense and law enforcement chiefs, former senior officials cautioned that recent developments threaten to cause a total loss of state control and trigger violent internal societal clashes.
At the center of the warning is a troubling public call circulating among certain groups urging Jews to arm themselves and prepare for confrontation while dismissing the authority of the state apparatus. The message explicitly rejects official security structures, asserting that citizens can no longer rely on the military, police, or the Shin Bet. Signatories to the letter condemned these pronouncements as an open call for rebellion and civil war that endangers the foundational existence of the nation.
Warning Issued to National Security Leaders
The letter was signed by former Mossad director and former head of the IDF Central Command Dani Yatom, alongside former Deputy National Security Advisor and organization CEO Itamar Yaar, speaking on behalf of numerous retired senior officials from the IDF, Mossad, Shin Bet, Israel Police, and the Foreign Ministry. The document was formally addressed to Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara, IDF Chief of the General Staff Eyal Zamir, Inspector General of the Israel Police Danny Levi, Shin Bet Director David Zini, and Yisrael Beytenu leader Avigdor Lieberman.
The authors outline a severe reality on the ground, asserting that unauthorized violence directed at Palestinian civilians by radical elements inflicts heavy casualties and destruction. According to the signatories, these perpetrators operate unchecked, defy orders from soldiers and police officers, and act as masters of the terrain while allegedly benefiting from tacit government backing.
Demand for Immediate State Intervention
The security veterans expressed deep concern that unauthorized militias operating outside the chain of command could soon turn their weapons against law enforcement personnel or plunge Israeli society into internal chaos. Concluding their communication, Yatom and Yaar demanded immediate, decisive intervention from the authorities to uphold public order, defend the democratic framework, and halt the proliferation of independent armed factions.





