US Judge Rejects Dismissal in Memory Chip Price-Fixing Lawsuit Against Samsung
A US federal judge rejected a motion to dismiss a class-action lawsuit accusing Samsung, Micron, and SK Hynix of conspiring to restrict standard memory chip supplies for AI dominance.

A United States federal judge in the Northern District of California, Noel Wise, has dealt a major legal blow to the world's three largest memory manufacturers by completely rejecting their motion to dismiss a massive class-action lawsuit. Samsung, Micron, and SK Hynix, which jointly control over 91% of global dynamic random-access memory market revenues, stand accused of illegal price-fixing and violating the Sherman Act to intentionally strangle the supply of standard memory chips utilized in personal computers and smartphones.
At the center of the complaint lies an astronomical price surge: conventional memory costs skyrocketed by 697% over an 18-month period, while retail store prices jumped by up to 500% within a single year. Plaintiffs, consisting of a group of consumers and small businesses from the USA, argue that instead of expanding production to match demand as dictated by a free market, the three companies coordinated parallel output cuts starting in late 2022. They aggressively diverted production lines tenfold toward High Bandwidth Memory chips designated for artificial intelligence accelerators.
The AI Pivot and Silicon Scarcity
The pivot toward the artificial intelligence sector generated an acute physical shortage of silicon raw materials. Because High Bandwidth Memory processors rely on vertically stacked chip layers, they consume three to four times more wafer area per gigabyte compared to standard DDR5 memory. According to the lawsuit, manufacturers exploited this situation to coordinate a sudden abandonment of DDR4 memory production in 2025, triggering panic buying among computer makers and leading to a distortion where older DDR4 components became costlier than cutting-edge DDR5 parts. As another extreme measure, Micron announced the closure of its long-standing and profitable consumer brand, Crucial, precisely at the peak of price hikes.
Alongside shuttering production lines, the companies are accused of locking up massive quantities of chips for artificial intelligence giants while abandoning the consumer market. Samsung and SK Hynix signed preliminary agreements to supply up to 40% of total global dynamic random-access memory output to OpenAI data center projects while refusing to sign long-term contracts with traditional computing clients. Furthermore, in early 2026 the three firms began enforcing identical and stringent customer-filtering procedures, interrogating buyers regarding end-user identities and demand authenticity—a practice reminiscent of the cartel monitoring methods for which the companies were previously convicted.
Judicial Rebuttal and Market Impact
Facing manufacturer claims that these represent independent and legitimate business decisions responding to artificial intelligence demand, similar to competitors watching each other like hawks in the sky, Judge Wise ruled decisively against the corporate position. The judge determined that the manufacturer conduct exceeded routine mutual surveillance and resembled hawks flying in a coordinated formation, an action hawks do not typically perform in nature. The court concluded that the sequence of decisions to shutter brands, delay factory construction, and refuse to increase supply amid record prices establishes a solid evidentiary foundation for pre-arranged coordination.
This legal upheaval unfolds during an unprecedented global supply crisis dubbed "RAMmageddon" within the hardware industry. While consumers grapple with surging costs for upgrading computers and smartphones, the memory divisions of these manufacturers enjoy record profitability with operating margins of 70% to 80% and quarterly revenues crossing the 41 billion dollar threshold. Industry experts warn that because constructing new manufacturing facilities requires years, memory component shortages will likely continue weighing on the market through at least the end of the decade.
Legally, the ruling does not constitute a final conviction, but it paves the way for the evidence discovery phase and the exposure of internal documents from the tech giants. The court ordered Samsung, Micron, and SK Hynix to submit their official statements of defense by early December ahead of preliminary hearings opening in January 2027. For millions of users worldwide who watched hardware prices double and triple, this legal battle marks an initial crack in the chip oligopoly and tests attempts to shift artificial intelligence costs onto the shoulders of private consumers.





