Knesset Legal Advisor Bars Gilad Kariv From Chair Special Committee
Knesset Legal Advisor Sagit Afik ruled that MK Gilad Kariv cannot chair a special committee reviewing a legal counsel bill due to a conflict of interest stemming from a pending criminal probe.

Legal Advisor to the Knesset Sagit Afik ruled that parliamentary discussions on the legal counsel bill must be transferred to a different special committee rather than being chaired by Member of Knesset Gilad Kariv. The issue emerged after the Knesset House Committee recommended selecting Kariv to head the special committee established to review the proposed legislation and the reversal of changes to the Judicial Selection Committee's composition.
Following the recommendation, the Lavi organization dispatched a pre-petition warning letter to the House Committee chairman and the Knesset Legal Advisor, demanding that the appointment be halted. The organization argued that Kariv is mired in a severe conflict of interest, noting that a decision regarding a criminal investigation against him—suspicious of leaking a classified protocol from the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee—rests with the Attorney General, while he is slated to lead legislation impacting the powers and status of legal advisors.
Kariv's Response and Ethics Precedent
In a letter to Sagit Afik, MK Kariv announced that he does not intend to preside over the specific bill's deliberations in order to prevent any appearance of impropriety. Responding to the preliminary allegations, Kariv stated that he would act in accordance with the directives of the Knesset legal counsel, emphasizing that his party will continue to campaign against legislation undermining institutional gatekeepers.
In her response, Afik cited a decision by the 25th Knesset Ethics Committee establishing that when a lawmaker is party to any legal proceeding involving a specific state body, a presumption of conflict of interest arises. Afik noted that due to the sweeping authorities vested in a committee chairman, merely recusing oneself from chairing specific sessions is insufficient to neutralize potential pressure or the perception of bias.
"In my view, the bill must be transferred to another special committee not chaired by you, which will further mitigate the concern of improper leverage and any appearance of impropriety in the legislative process," wrote Sagit Afik.
Nevertheless, the Knesset Legal Advisor clarified that Kariv will remain permitted to participate in the deliberations of the alternative special committee and vote on the legislation, subject to the fulfillment of disclosure obligations.





