Israel Railways Faces Severe Liquidity Risks Amid Surging Payroll and Losses

Government regulators warned that Israel Railways faces immediate liquidity risks and severe profitability erosion due to surging payroll costs and workforce expansion that outpaced operational output.

Israel Railways Faces Severe Liquidity Risks Amid Surging Payroll and Losses
Photo: Unsplash / @hamburgmeinefreundin (Hamburg Meine Freundin)

The Government Companies Authority has issued a severe warning regarding Israel Railways, pointing to an immediate liquidity risk driven by soaring payroll expenses and plummeting profitability. According to an official report covering the performance period from 2019 to 2025, the rail operator's wage costs surged by approximately 60 percent, rising from roughly 1.05 billion shekels to about 1.66 billion shekels. Concurrently, the workforce expanded by 37 percent, increasing from 3,749 to 5,145 employees.

Workforce Expansion Outpaces Operational Output

The explosive growth in personnel contrasted sharply with stagnant operational outputs over the same period. Passenger numbers edged up by just 4 percent, track infrastructure grew by 4 percent, train mileage increased by 7 percent, and the average daily number of operating trains rose by 8 percent. The report notes that had staff numbers scaled proportionally with the 6 percent average increase in output, Israel Railways would employ only 3,974 workers, leaving a surplus of 1,171 positions.

Discrepancies are most prominent within the development division, where staff levels spiked by 133 percent from 222 workers in 2019 to 518 in 2025. Regulators criticized this massive influx of manpower for failing to prevent substantial project delays. The authority concluded that fixed overhead expenses grew disproportionately to productivity, denying the public the expected service improvements.

Profitability Erasure and Freight Losses

Financial margins have steadily eroded over the past several years. Although annual revenues climbed from roughly 2.56 billion shekels in 2019 to approximately 3.65 billion shekels in 2025, the net profit dropped to a razor-thin 56.5 million shekels, representing a profit margin of just 1.55 percent. The downward trend accelerated sharply into 2026, with the gross profit margin tumbling from 12.6 percent in 2023 to 1.8 percent. During the first half of 2026, Israel Railways posted an operating loss equivalent to 3.85 percent of revenues and a net loss of 1.45 percent, exacerbated by security impacts from Operation Roaring Lion.

The freight division emerged as a primary financial drain. While freight revenues stagnated around 324 million shekels by 2025, annual operating losses nearly doubled from 33.6 million shekels to 62.6 million shekels, pushing the loss-to-revenue ratio from 10.3 percent to 19.3 percent. Meanwhile, the commercial sector remained a bright spot with a high profit margin of 63.5 percent generating 45.3 million shekels in profit, though it accounts for less than 2 percent of total company revenues.

Liquidity Pressures and Immediate Demands

The Government Companies Authority emphasized that the combination of negative operational cash flow, operating losses, and a lack of defined financial buffers leaves the company heavily reliant on state transfer timings, working capital loans, and debt write-offs. Furthermore, regulators found that Israel Railways violates government circular guidelines by operating without an official liquidity risk management policy, relying instead on its current cash balance.

In response to these findings, the authority demands immediate corrective measures, including workforce rationalization, freight division restructuring, and the establishment of a mandatory liquidity buffer approved by the board of directors. These financial warnings coincide with an extended leadership vacuum at Israel Railways, which has operated without a permanent CEO since Moshe Zana stepped down in August 2025, leaving Avshalom Elmaliach as acting CEO under board chairman Avner Flor.

Management Response and Defense

Rejecting the severity of the financial critique, Israel Railways defended its operational record, citing record-breaking performance levels:

"Israel Railways is a premier state-owned enterprise, serving over 300,000 passengers daily while continuously upgrading infrastructure to meet surging demand. Last year, the company carried a record 72 million passenger journeys."

Company management also criticized external bodies for leveraging the financial repercussions of Operation Roaring Lion—costs that have not yet been fully covered by the state—to undermine the railway's fiscal performance. Leadership affirmed its commitment to internal audits and continued public service under all security conditions.

Related News