High Court Orders Health Clinic Built in Shuafat Refugee Camp After Decades
The High Court of Justice ordered the Ministry of Health and Jerusalem to establish a maternal health clinic in Shuafat, ending decades of delays for residents living beyond the security barrier.

The High Court of Justice has ordered the Ministry of Health and the Jerusalem municipality to establish a Tipat Chalav maternal and child health clinic in the Shuafat refugee camp. The facility will also serve the adjacent neighborhoods of Ras Khamis, Ras Shehada, and Diyat a-Salam, which fall within Jerusalem's municipal jurisdiction but lie beyond the security barrier.
Court Ruling and Background
The ruling stems from a petition filed in 2021 by five mothers from northeastern Jerusalem alongside the Association for Civil Rights in Israel. According to the petition, thousands of children under the age of six and numerous pregnant women reside in these neighborhoods without access to a local health clinic. To receive basic services such as routine vaccinations, developmental tracking, and prenatal care, residents were forced to travel to other parts of the city, enduring security checkpoints and delays lasting hours.
Delivering the court's decision, Justice Daphne Barak-Erez ruled that the current situation constitutes an unjustified violation of the right to health and breaches the National Health Insurance Law, which mandates that medical services be provided within a reasonable time and distance. The respondents never contested the need for the clinic, but the project faced a succession of bureaucratic setbacks over two decades, including canceled tenders, frozen modular building plans, and abandoned mobile unit proposals.
Implementation Deadlines and Municipal Efforts
Under the court-ordered timeline, a permanent clinic is slated to be built within a municipal public building complex, a process expected to take three to five years. In the interim, authorities must launch a temporary facility in a rented building within the camp by February 1, 2027, or alternatively deploy a mobile health service by that date while completing the permanent structure by July 1, 2027. Additionally, the state and the municipality were ordered to pay 30,000 shekels in legal costs to the petitioners.
In recent years, Jerusalem Mayor Moshe Lion has spearheaded development initiatives across East Jerusalem to bridge municipal gaps, allocating hundreds of millions of shekels toward infrastructure, education, transportation, and public spaces in Arab neighborhoods. Justice Barak-Erez noted the historical significance of the ruling, recalling that Israel's first preventive healthcare clinic was established in Jerusalem's Old City in 1921 by Dr. Helena Kagan.
"The time has come for this historic enterprise to extend across the entirety of the city of Jerusalem," wrote Justice Barak-Erez.
Attorney Tal Chassin of the Association for Civil Rights in Israel welcomed the decision, stating that the court has finally intervened to provide critical healthcare access to tens of thousands of residents isolated behind the barrier.





