Hartman Survey Reveals Secular Anxieties Over Jewish Studies in Schools
A new Hartman Institute survey shows 84% of Israelis support Jewish heritage studies in schools, yet 57% of secular citizens fear increased religious coercion and lifestyle changes.

A new survey published by the Hartman Institute ahead of the upcoming government formation reveals a complex landscape in Israel's state education system. While an overwhelming majority of Israelis support teaching Jewish heritage, secular families express deep-seated anxieties that increased religious studies could lead to creeping religious coercion and alter their children's lifestyles.
According to the data, 57% of secular respondents believe that an approach favoring "more Judaism" in schools risks precipitating religious coercion. Furthermore, 41% worry that school curricula will "spill over" into home life, pushing their children to adopt religious practices against family preferences. These concerns are amplified by a visible post-October 7 trend among many teenagers who have voluntarily embraced religious traditions, such as putting on tefillin, observing the Sabbath, and adopting modest attire.
Despite these reservations, the survey highlights a broad consensus for cultural and historical engagement with Judaism. Overall, 84% of respondents believe public schools should teach about Judaism from historical, cultural, and ideological perspectives, with 77% supporting experiential participation in holidays and rituals. Among secular participants alone, 79% endorse historical and cultural instruction, demonstrating that the primary dispute centers not on whether to study Jewish heritage, but on how it is taught and who controls the curriculum.
Autonomy in Education and the Upcoming Conference
The findings show that 63% of the general sample support transferring responsibility for Jewish content directly to school teaching staffs, aligning curriculum with the ethos of individual school communities rather than enforcing uniform top-down directives. While religious publics heavily favor adding instruction hours, secular communities reject uniform expansion, preferring localized autonomy.
Ronit Had, Vice President of the Hartman Institute and director of the Center for Israeli and Jewish Identity, emphasized that Jewish heritage and democracy are complementary. "The Israeli public wants more Judaism, but not more coercion," Had stated, noting that education must foster identity without provoking fear. The survey findings will be officially presented at the upcoming third international education conference, "Imagine," scheduled for November 23. During the event, the Hartman Institute and the Hussidman Foundation will lead a dedicated session addressing how educators can navigate controversial questions of Jewish and democratic identity in the classroom, alongside eight leading educational foundations and funds.





