Haifa Court Orders Police to Pay 202,000 Shekels Over Negligent High-Speed Pursuit

A Haifa court ordered Israel Police and a fleeing driver to pay 202,000 shekels to an insurance firm, ruling that a botched high-speed pursuit and unblocked spike strips caused a crash.

Haifa Court Orders Police to Pay 202,000 Shekels Over Negligent High-Speed Pursuit
Photo: Amit Lonen / Wikimedia Commons

The Magistrate's Court in Haifa ordered the state and a fleeing driver to jointly pay approximately 202,000 shekels in property damage compensation to an insurance company following a negligent police pursuit.

Judge Jada Bassoul ruled that Israel Police acted with carelessness and disproportion during an incident on August 8, 2023, failing to halt civilian traffic before deploying spike strips at a major intersection in Caesarea. The court upheld a subrogation lawsuit filed by AIG, which compensated its policyholders after two innocent vehicles—a Lexus and a Chevrolet—were struck by the suspect.

Chronology of the Pursuit

The incident began when a motorist refused to present a driver's license at a planned checkpoint and fled the scene. During the initial escape, a bag containing cannabis was thrown from the vehicle, prompting an officer to stop and retrieve it, which temporarily broke visual contact with the suspect. The pursuit was subsequently resumed by a detective driving an unmarked vehicle, reaching speeds of up to 160 kilometers per hour over approximately ten minutes.

Upon learning that the fleeing car was heading toward the Pal-Yam intersection in Caesarea, officers deployed spike strips on the roadway. However, police failed to stop civilian traffic or post warning signs for approaching motorists. The fleeing vehicle drove over the spike strips, entered the intersection against a red light, and violently collided with a police cruiser and two private cars crossing lawfully on a green signal.

Court Findings and Legal Arguments

The fleeing driver was previously convicted in criminal proceedings through a plea bargain and sentenced to 42 months of actual imprisonment.

Israel Police argued that the lawsuit should be dismissed, maintaining that officers responded professionally and proportionally to avert a public danger, and that sole liability rested with the escaping driver.

Represented by attorneys Yitzhak Luzon, Limor Per-Luzon, and Hali Ben-Shitrit, the insurance company contended that while police authority to apprehend criminals is undisputed, the operation violated internal guidelines and standards of care.

"The resulting picture is one of actions carried out not in accordance with procedure, and this is not a single deviation, but an accumulation of matters," Judge Bassoul stated in the verdict. "Thus, it can be concluded that the police actions were carried out negligently and without sufficient caution, causing the accident and the damage."

In addition to the property damage payout, the state was ordered to cover legal expenses and attorney fees amounting to approximately 18,000 shekels. The court also approved a third-party claim filed by the state against the fleeing driver, ordering him to indemnify the authorities for all sums paid to the insurance company.

Related News