El Al Petitions Supreme Court Over 29,000 Shekel Passenger Compensation Ruling

El Al petitioned the Supreme Court to overturn a ruling requiring carriers to fund 16 nights of lodging for stranded passengers during airspace closures, citing major industry impacts.

El Al Petitions Supreme Court Over 29,000 Shekel Passenger Compensation Ruling
Photo: El Al Official Brand Identity

El Al Israel Airlines has petitioned the Supreme Court for leave to appeal a District Court ruling that obligates the carrier to fund 16 nights of accommodation abroad for a family stranded during the "Operation With All My Heart" airspace closure.

The airline argues that the ruling establishes a sweeping legal precedent, forcing carriers to shoulder unlimited financial liability for passenger upkeep whenever state-mandated airspace closures prevent operations. According to El Al, the precedent sets a binding standard for lower courts, exposing the aviation industry to immense cumulative costs during security crises over which operators have no operational control.

Origins of the Legal Dispute

The case stems from a claim filed by passenger Uri Dahan, his wife, and four children, who purchased return tickets to Kraków from El Al. Following the closure of Israeli airspace on June 13, 2025, due to security operations, the family's return flight on June 17 was canceled. Dahan was eventually assigned to a rescue flight on July 2, 2025, remaining abroad for 16 days.

He subsequently filed a small claims lawsuit seeking reimbursement for 18,501 shekels in accommodation, 4,783 shekels in transport, and 9,056 shekels in food and beverages. While the Small Claims Court initially awarded compensation covering only four nights of lodging, the District Court sustained the passenger's appeal and expanded the compensation to cover all 16 nights, totaling 29,000 shekels for the six-person family.

Broader Industry Implications and Legal Arguments

El Al maintains that the Aviation Services Law was designed to regulate routine operational disruptions and incentivize carriers to minimize cancellations, rather than to impose unconstrained financial obligations during state-enforced national security shutdowns. The airline noted that section 9a of the law empowers the Minister of Transport to issue decrees capping lodging liabilities during emergencies, though no such decree was enacted for this specific operation.

Furthermore, the carrier emphasizes that simultaneous petitions have been lodged with the High Court of Justice seeking clarity on whether assistance duties apply during state-ordered airspace closures. El Al warns that leaving the current District Court interpretation intact risks deterring foreign airlines from maintaining routes to Israel, ultimately reducing market competition and raising consumer prices.

Passenger Counsel Response

Representing the passenger, attorney Barak Shemony defended the District Court verdict as a correct application of consumer protection legislation.

"The Aviation Services Law is a distinct consumer protection statute designed to safeguard passenger rights, particularly when individuals are left helpless far from home. The legislature explicitly accounted for emergency situations by establishing a mechanism to limit lodging entitlements via appropriate decrees, which were not issued for these operations."

Shemony asserted that shifting the economic burden of wartime disruptions onto stranded consumers contradicts the statute's legislative intent, arguing that questions of cost-allocation during national emergencies belong in arrangements between the state and carriers rather than being absorbed by individual travelers.

Related News