Housing Crisis Deepens in Arab Municipalities Amid Low Budget Execution

Data reveals severe implementation gaps in housing budgets for Arab municipalities, where execution rates fell to 15.6% in 2024 despite multi-billion shekel allocations.

Housing Crisis Deepens in Arab Municipalities Amid Low Budget Execution
Photo: דוברות המשטרה

The ongoing coalition negotiations and political shifts following the swearing-in of the 26th Knesset have placed renewed focus on systemic policy disparities, particularly regarding housing crises in Arab municipalities. Data compiled by the Mossad Center through freedom of information requests concerning Government Resolution 550 highlights a deep implementation gap where allocated state funds fail to materialize on the ground.

While the resolution earmarked approximately 2.1 billion shekels for housing over five years—short of the 8 billion shekels estimated necessary by the Ministry of Construction and Housing in 2021—actual execution rates plummeted. Expenditures reached 35.7% in 2022, 33.5% in 2023, and just 15.6% in 2024. A designated 200 million shekel item for subsidizing infrastructure in multi-story construction on state land remained entirely unfunded, while current ministry estimates indicate closing the socioeconomic and spatial gap requires roughly 15 billion shekels.

Administrative Bottlenecks and Canceled Blueprints

Residential marketing projects in Arab localities have stalled since 2023 following the cancellation of land price discounts and local residency preferences in Israel Land Authority tenders. In Jisr az-Zarqa, hundreds of housing units were marketed under highest-bidder rules, leaving local residents requiring affordable housing without viable options. Meanwhile, the Planning Administration disbursed only about 118 million shekels out of 250 million earmarked by the end of 2023 to strengthen local committees and engineering units, with actual payments reported as negligible.

At the same time, major strategic blueprints have faced severe cuts or outright cancellation:

  • In Kuseife, a master plan encompassing 27,543 housing units alongside commercial and industrial zones was canceled.
  • In Umm al-Fahm, the Ayn Jarrar project meant to supply roughly 6,500 housing units was compromised by spatial separation lines and the designation of homes for demolition.
  • In Sakhnin, Arraba, and Eilabun, municipal development perimeters were systematically reduced.

Economic Toll and Policy Recommendations

Economist Salem Abbasi of the Mossad Center, operating in cooperation with the Friedrich Ebert Foundation, emphasizes that the direct economic toll includes lost construction opportunities, constrained employment, diminished property tax revenues, and stifled private investment. Over the past decade, more than 30,000 structures have been demolished as the state prioritizes enforcement over generating sustainable housing solutions.

Experts stress that the incoming government must overhaul the planning apparatus to reflect actual land ownership realities in Arab towns, restore localized land purchase preferences, and embed budgets directly into regular ministerial baselines rather than relying on temporary five-year plans. Integrating Arab professionals into planning institutions—where representation currently stands at roughly 4%—remains a vital step toward resolving a crisis that ultimately constrains Israel's broader economic growth potential.

Related News